I'm writing to update you on what we want from the next government and how Farmlands shareholders can hold their board to account over AgriZero.
We have a likely election result, but it’s close enough that the politicians are still in a holding pattern until the special votes come out at the end of the month. That makes this exactly the time to tell the parties what we expect to see in the coalition agreements they're starting to negotiate.
And if you’re a Farmlands shareholder, you can do something about the AgriZero rort yourself at the AGM on 24 November. Click here to find out what's at stake, how to vote, or appoint a proxy to vote for you: https://www.groundswellnz.co.nz/news/farmlands-agm-2026
The next government has work to do
1. Quit Paris
The Paris Agreement remains a uniquely bad deal for New Zealand. Other countries can shut down coal power stations and claim they're "taking climate action" and so on, but New Zealand already had a largely renewable electricity grid and an efficient farming sector when the clock started. We feed tens of millions of people, and every tonne of emissions from producing that food counts against New Zealand. No prizes for us for the "climate action" of feeding people with lower emissions than they can feed themselves.
A Farming Tax or some other policy trying to arbitrarily reduce New Zealand's agricultural emissions, will just production to higher-emitting farms overseas. The politicians get their applause overseas, the bureaucrats get their numbers ticking the right way for their reports, and the activists get to feel good about themselves. All while there's no way for any of that to benefit the climate, Kiwi farmers and rural communities pay the price with hollowed out jobs and incomes, and everyone pays the price at the supermarket.
We fought off one Farming Tax. As long as governments keep signing up to targets they have no credible plan to meet, someone will come back for another go. That’s why we say Quit Paris.
But we know coalition agreements are about compromise and the parties have a lot to trade off. While NZ First campaigned on withdrawing and ACT has their detailed Change or Leave plan, Christopher Luxon at least said he was dead set on staying in Paris: a "bottom line", even. But it isn't just his coalition partners, Mr Luxon may want to have a quick check around his caucus now, before he insists on sticking with his allegiance to the international climate industry.
If staying is necessary in the short term, the least National can do is come to the table on ACT’s Change or Leave proposal. Set some realistic targets and not Jacinda Ardern's and James Shaw's 50% reduction that had no basis in reality, but which Luxon and Simon Watts doubled down on. Treat short-lived methane separately from carbon dioxide, which is now obvious to even the UN and IPCC crowd. And rule out a price on agricultural emissions.
We'll see who holds which portfolios going forward, but National's Climate Change and Trade and Agriculture ministers should be standing up for Kiwi farmers and selling our exports to the world however they can. Like pointing out how the Paris Agreement explicitly says reducing emissions shouldn't be done in a way that threatens food supply. If some market does want low-emissions food at scale (though we've yet to see that be more than rhetoric and pilot schemes), that should include pointing out how emissions-efficient we are, instead of apologising for being the best farmers in the world.
What's more, most of those Change or Leave changes from ACT wouldn't even breach Opportunity's stated bottom line on staying Paris and keeping the Climate Change Commission. It's time for National to remember when it called itself "friend of the farmer" and at least be friendlier than the party of the Land Tax.
2. Defund AgriZeroNZ
When politicians and industry leaders were trying to sell us the Farming Tax, AgriZero was supposed to find the technology farmers would need to keep up with it. The tax was dropped. The Government is still matching the banks and agribusinesses dollar for dollar, and the scheme now has $308 million in public and private backing.
If an overseas customer wants milk or meat produced using a methane bolus, let them tell farmers what premium they’ll pay for it. Then farmers can decide whether it stacks up. In the meantime, why are taxpayers underwriting the bet? The government’s books are under strain. That taxpayer money could go to hospitals and schools, or even back to taxpayers. Instead, it’s going to the AgriZero rort.
Farmers say in survey after survey that they don't want to use methane inhibitor technology on their livestock. In our most recent survey, with the Methane Science Accord and NZ Farming, 76% of farmers surveyed said they they would not actively pursue methane reduction. Only 2-3% said they would use methane inhibition, like a methane vaccine or bolus. From that, we can tell that the AgriZero project is clearly not on the same page as farmers. But with 92% saying other agricultural research priorities should receive greater attention and funding, it's clear AgriZero is a major misallocation of resources by the government and the industry.
If the money has to go to the environment anyway, farmers and local communities are taking real local action on the ground by restoring native bush, fencing streams, and getting on with work that makes a difference in reality. It might be novel for government, but perhaps backing what already works would be the place to start.
3. Scrap Freshwater Farm Plans
The Coalition's RMA reforms sounded great at the start: "property rights enshrined in law" and so on. But the actual law we've got now leaves enormous scope for a creative future Environment Minister to add compliance costs by regulation. We appear to have dodged the threat of such a minister this election (though we're not out of the woods yet). One day, though, the next David Parker will come along with another bright idea like the winter grazing rule that would have required Southland farmers to resow by 1 November, regardless of spring conditions.
It's easy to forget now that's how bad it was, but there's nothing in the law to stop a future government from doing it again. In fact, Freshwater Farm Plans add another way to heap compliance on farms without even needing to go back to Parliament to make new laws.
The Coalition promised to make farm plans more practical and less costly, saying the farm plans would save paperwork for farmers who currently need a resource consent and fend off demands from the activists for harder regulation. We understand the appeal of that kind of argument, but it's exactly the kind of appeasement we saw in how the Farming Tax and HWEN (He Waka Eke Noa) debates went. There isn't a good faith debate going on about regulations on farming. Compromising with the anti-farming factions just encourages them. For those who want the full weight of the state coming down on family farms, the existence of these farm plans is not going to slow them down one bit. Instead, it will let them speed things up by already giving them the legislative tools to get started.
And what about the farms that can operate without a consent today? It’s a strange definition of cutting red tape to bring more farms into the reporting scheme than there were beforehand. At the least, the Coalition should futureproof Freshwater Farm Plans against the future activist minister we know is coming. And start with exempting the farms that didn't need a consent under the old scheme would be the bare minimum.
They may not want to think about a future where they're out of office. Those of us trying to plan the future of our farms and communities have to.
4. End the Section 6 Land Grab
The old Section 6 number is gone from the replacement laws, but much of the old approach has survived. Councils can still arbitrarily put lines on a map and use broad, vague classifications to restrict what people do with their own land. We’ve seen where that leads in Gore. A rule written into a district plan can leave an owner paying more to use or improve their property, while the council gets to say it was just following the rules.
What farmer is going to plant another stand of native bush, if looking after it could leave them with fewer rights over their land? Turning good conservation into a liability is bad for the environment, the land owners, and the people who just want to enjoy the scenery.
The Government promised a planning system built around property rights and stopped new Significant Natural Areas (SNAs). But SNAs were always just the highest-profile of the Section 6 Land Grab classifications and the existing ones are still there. The problem is the legislation does not back the land owner against the whim of a council bureaucrat holding a map and a clipboard.
The next government must rip out the Section 6 legacy in the new laws and make councils justify the restrictions they place on private land by the actual effects it has on the owner and the local community. The traditional way to handle when the government takes people's property (which is what a land classification does to the owner's rights over their land), is to pay them for it.
And still, the most effective land preservation systems in New Zealand are the voluntary schemes that already work, like QEII covenants.
5. Dealing with Opportunity
If the numbers mean a deal with Opportunity is required, National must keep to the overlap between the parties and not give away compromises on old battles already won. Some of Opportunity policy sounds just fine, others could be fine if the right negotiator sets the terms, but others are real threats to farming from the worst of the regulatory onslaught we saw just a few years ago.
For one, the old Te Mana o te Wai hierarchy must not be allowed to return to any level of government. For those who have understandably suppressed the memory, that was Labour's plan to make councils prioritise the “wellbeing” of water ahead of any human use of the water. It's not in their bottom lines, but Opportunity say they want it back. To let that slip through would be an utter betrayal of the Coalition's voters.
Opportunity's policy to support landowners with "profitable biodiversity credit markets" could be made into some scheme to pay landowners for the classifications put on their land and the environmental action farmers are already taking. That could be an improvement over the status quo, but they also mention Significant Natural Areas in the same policy. Any scheme like that must be strictly voluntary and the Coalition would have to ensure that no backdoor to reintroducing SNAs is on the cards.
Similarly, Opportunity say they want "encouragement" for farmers to use water storage that supports native biodiversity. If that means funding or positive incentives for farmers looking after their local environment to the benefit of everyone, then maybe fair enough. But we've seen how the government wanting to look at private water pipes and storage turns into state overreach before, as with the attempted 2022 Drinking Water Rules.
If there's going to be a deal, the current Coalition has the scope to find Opportunity policies that fit the ideas the Coalition say they believe in. Opening up the worst of the Ardern-era counterproductive idealistic environmentalism, and how it led to unworkable regulations, should not be on the table.
Farmlands shareholders, use your vote
Farmlands shareholders have been flooding our inboxes after the news that the Farmlands board is buying into the AgriZero scheme. It's clear there are too many who don't want this for the board to have acted on its own like this, theoretically on behalf of their shareholders.
Our basic point is simple. AgriZero fundamentally misunderstands NZ farming as a problem to be solved, when farming isn't the problem at all. Then, because there isn't a problem to solve, they're stuck chasing fantasies of methane inhibiting injections and boluses, which our customers just don't want to eat. These fantasies are so unlikely that they cost hundreds of millions of dollars to pursue. Even if you want to spend on climate change, this is the wrong way to do it.
It's one thing for a scheme like this to pop out of the dark days of the Farming Tax, and while it's a shame this Government has kept it going, farmers are having to pay three times over for politicians and industry leadership to feel good about spending other people's money
We all pay through taxes. Then farmers pay as customers of the big corporates who funnel their profit margins into the scheme. Now, it’s coming out of our own co-op as well. Taxpayer. Customer. Shareholder. How many times over are farmers supposed to pay for a scheme that starts from the wrong idea that farming is the problem?
Farmlands is a rural supply co-op and not an investment bank, let alone a green one. Then, there's the added insult that the Farmlands chairman, Rob Hewett, is also the chairman of AgriZeroNZ. To be clear, we aren't alleging wrongdoing. The Farmlands board has made very clear that they believe all the required legal steps were taken to declare and manage conflicts of interest. Our point is that the legal steps are not enough. This transaction is at odds with the goals and purposes of the Farmlands cooperative, while the board chair supposed to be governing the co-op on behalf of shareholders is chair of the scheme the money is going to. We think the roles are fundamentally incompatible.
If you do too, and you're a Farmlands shareholder, you can do something about it. The Farmlands AGM is on 24 November and there will be shareholder votes on AgriZero and Rob Hewett's directorship.
You can attend in person in Gore, attend online through Farmlands' website portal, or give your proxy to someone to will attend and vote on your behalf.
Groundswell co-founder Laurie Paterson is available to hold your proxy for you and represent you at the meeting if you would like.
Read up on how to participate, what the votes will be, and how to tell Farmlands whether you'll attend in person, online, or file a proxy from our guide here: https://www.groundswellnz.co.nz/news/farmlands-agm-2026.
This goes beyond Farmlands, too. There are good people on boards and senior roles in the Ag Sector, but too often it’s the same faces turning up to tell grassroots farmers, growers, and rural communities what’s good for us. And the transmission is usually one-way. Often, the good people are stuck between those who think they know better than the people they're supposed to serve and the politicians and activists making demands. They've compromised because that's what was on the table. This is an opportunity to put the whole sector on notice: the grassroots farmer and our rural communities won't be ignored or lectured. And it will give the real farmers' representatives the back-up they need to push for change.
At the AGM, shareholders can tell the Board to look for a way out and insist on a vote before it puts any more of their money in.
It only takes a few minutes to sort the paperwork. There’s no use complaining at the pub afterwards if you leave your vote at home.
Vote in Gore or online on Tuesday, 24 November, or appoint an independent proxy by 6.30pm on Sunday, 22 November.
If you’d like to follow more closely, there is a Facebook page for Farmlands shareholders opposed to AgriZero investment. You can join them here: https://www.facebook.com/groups/1407933694269645
A word on the election result
Before polling day we wrote about how splitting your votes could create an overhang. On the preliminary count, more than 700,000 party votes bought National precisely zero list MPs. Its party vote was enough for 35 seats, but it won 42 electorates and gets to keep them all. That’s seven extra seats for National and four for the Maori Party.
On party votes alone, National, ACT and NZ First would have had 60 of 120 seats. With the overhang they’re on 67 out of 131, one seat above the majority they need. Now, we wait for the special votes to come through.
Thank you again for your support.
Kind regards,
Bryce, Laurie, and the Team at Groundswell NZ
