News & Media
Press Release
Resource

Groundswell responds to Farmlands AGM claims

Groundswell NZ

Looking for details about how to participate in the 2026 Farmlands AGM? Click here to find out.

Farmlands and AgriZeroNZ chairman Rob Hewett seems to have gotten a little confused in an email he sent to certain Farmlands shareholders about remits they'll be voting on at Tuesday's AGM. So, to help him out, we've written this quick explainer with how we got here, what Groundswell's role is, and how we're thinking about the votes.

How we got here

The first thing to make absolutely clear, is that Groundswell NZ has not filed any remits. Groundswell NZ Co-founder Laurie Paterson is a Farmlands shareholder and he has put forward remit 8, to end the Farmlands directorship of Mr Hewett. While we wouldn't split hairs over someone calling that a “Groundswell remit”, Laurie is doing that under his own name.

Of course, Groundswell NZ supports the remit, but we're most focused on ensuring grassroots farmers and rural community members engage with the accountability systems of our Ag Sector institutions. Farmlands is your co-op, it should work for you. We know most farmers don't want a bar of the methane inhibitor experiments like the boluses and injections AgriZeroNZ is working on. And we also know only a tiny minority of Farmlands shareholders usually participate in its governance processes. So, we're just saying that shareholders should have their say on the running of their co-op. If the worry for some is that the shareholders may get what they want, there might need to be a bit of a rethink about who works for whom, here.

As for why we support Laurie's remit, it's fairly simple. We think AgriZero is not working in the interests of grassroots farmers and growers, or of rural communities and taxpayers. Farmlands has paid to join the AgriZero scheme, and we agree with the many shareholders who think that kind of “investment” is not in line with the purposes of the Farmlands co-op. Mr Hewett is the chair of the boards of both organisations. The combination of AgriZero’s goals, Farmlands’ purposes, the money changing hands, and the overlapping governance, has led us to also agree with those shareholders who think that the two roles are incompatible. The interests of Farmlands shareholders and the goals of the AgriZero scheme are just too different.

And, to be even clearer, we aren't accusing anyone of anything untoward here. As far as we know, Farmlands is correct in saying all the necessary steps were taken to manage the conflict of interest. Meeting legal standards is not the only standard shareholders can hold their directors to, of course.

What Mr Hewett got wrong

Second, Groundswell is not backing all the shareholder remits or opposing all of the board's. Shareholders will make up their own minds, but we outline below what we think, which is also how Laurie has said he will vote. But we have to directly address some misconceptions in Mr Hewett's email:

  • He says we are the source of the remit to prohibit board members from holding other directorships: “Proposed changes from groundswell to Farmlands governance rules…”. Groundswell did not propose remit 7 and we do not support it. Laurie has said he will be voting against it.
  • Similarly, for the remits about board members, Groundswell does not aim to block Will Clarke’s confirmation. We consider auditing Mr Hewett to be a step too far and beyond the proper scope of a shareholder meeting. We do, of course, oppose the confirmation of Mr Hewett and support Laurie’s remit to remove him.
  • And, on Mr Hewett’s claim that we “deliberately missed the economic implications”, the truth is that we have a differing view on the economic claims that Mr Hewett and the backers of AgriZero have yet to interact with. As is often the case on these counts, Mr Hewett has followed the statements of the corporates and politicians overseas, but failed to look at their revealed preferences: they want our food for its competitive quality and price. If they really want low-emissions food, then Kiwi farmers are already the cutting edge.

Our view on the remits

         BOARD RESOLUTIONS

  1. Adopt the 2026 Annual Report - YES
  2. Keep Deloitte as auditor - YES
  3. Confirm Rob Hewett's reappointment for 3 years - NO
  4. Confirm Will Clarke's reappointment for 3 years - YES

    SHAREHOLDER PROPOSALS
    ‍
  5. Audit the Chair's personal finances and his companies - NO
  6. Reverse the AgriZeroNZ investment and hold a shareholder referendum - YES
  7. Ban directors and the CEO from holding any other directorship - NO
  8. Remove Rob Hewett from the Board now - YES
  9. Ask the Board to look at exiting AgriZeroNZ and report back in 3 months - YES
  10. Require a 75% shareholder vote before any further investment in AgriZeroNZ or methane-reduction products - YES

So we hope that helps Mr Hewett understand the situation and the Groundswell view on the AGM. If he intends to send more emails out to select shareholders, we hope they will stick to the facts.

Rob Hewett's email

For your information, we include the text of the email here:

I'm following up my email below regarding the gathering of proxies for the upcoming Farmlands AGM. As you'll be aware, groundswell and the methane accord, along with one other Farmlands shareholder have proposed 6 additional resolutions for voting on at the upcoming AGM. All of the detail is included in the Notice of Meeting email appended below (go to the "Notice of Meeting" button for more detail - below). The Board has given clear guidance on the way we would prefer votes to be lodged, but it is your decision. We'd like your support.

‍
It is critical that you exercise your right to vote. A small group of motivated shareholders are threatening to severely impact and curtail the way Farmlands can operate in the future, particularly with regard to the potential to range products that sit in two of our key strategic parts of the business - animal health and nutrition. It is important that you have the right to choice and optionality with regards to selecting products that are right for your business. If Farmlands is restricted in selling them to you - which it will be if proposal 10 is passed - you will still likely buy them elsewhere if you think them important enough to your business's ongoing success. This sort of restriction is highly likely to have unintended flow on consequences for other parts of our business as well. Vote no to proposed resolution 10.

‍
Proposed changes from groundswell to Farmlands governance rules will significantly limit the company's ability to attract and source the best governance candidates from our shareholder base, through the limitation of the number of directorships a person can hold. As framed right now, the whole Board would have to resign if this proposal is passed. Recruiting replacement governors with sufficient skills, perspective and experience to govern a company of Farmlands size and complexity, given this self-imposed shooting-yourself-in-the-foot, unnecessary limitation will be nigh on impossible. Vote no to proposed resolution 7.

‍
Both groundswell and the methane accord have deliberately missed the economic implications of their proposed remits. Put simply, New Zealand's customers off shore who pay premiums for the products you currently sell from your farms through the likes of Fonterra, Alliance, Synlait, Silver Fern Farms, A2 and Anzco have a bundle of desirable attributes they seek. One of these attributes is evidence of emissions reduction over time. New Zealand's free trade agreements with the EU and UK have this requirement built in as well. Ignoring the market, or even more inflammatory, telling the customers that they are wrong is simply not a good negotiating tactic. As a country, we need to be aware of and respond to these customers' needs in order to maintain relevance and premiums into the future. Farmlands has invested in Agrizero to allow our animal feed business (Seales Winslow) and our animal health business (Donaghys) to have a first mover advantage in bringing these products to you should you want them for your business. Vote no to proposed resolutions 6, 9 & 10.

‍
Finally, succession planning around the Farmlands board will be impacted significantly negatively if groundswell and the methane accord have their way. Both myself as current chair (with one term left), and Will Clarke as a potential chair successor (with up to four terms left) could be off the Board next Wednesday if the proposed remits get traction. We are already down one farmer director with Claire Nicholson having recently resigned for personal reasons, and both Dawn Sangster and Gray Baldwin will be rotating off the board next year at the limit of their 3 term tenure (9 years). We have succession plans well advanced, but to be in a situation where potentially five of the six farmer directors will not be on the Board next year will significantly negatively impact these plans. Vote Yes to resolutions 3 & 4, vote no to proposed resolution 5 & 8.

‍
As per the attached Notice of Meeting, the Board strongly recommends you support resolutions 1-4 inclusive by voting yes and do not support proposed resolutions 5-10 by voting no.

If you prefer, you can direct your proxies to a member of the Board, or someone who is attending the meeting on the day. The Board has already said they are unable to alter your voting preferences if you have directed them - we will vote them as you have indicated. However, if you give the Board an undirected proxy, they will be voted as per above.

Have your vote, have your say. Don't let a small vocal minority who is spreading misinformation and "alternative facts" take control of the business you own.

Thanks, Rob

‍

Read more